Articles on Primal Therapy, psychogenesis, causes of psychological traumas, brain development, psychotherapies, neuropsychology, neuropsychotherapy. Discussions about causes of anxiety, depression, psychosis, consequences of the birth trauma and life before birth.
Sunday, March 31, 2013
On Killing Pain
Am I missing something? Here is today’s headline in the L.A. Times (March 30-13):
DEATHS TIED TO PAINKILLERS RISING IN U.S. (See http://articles.latimes.com/2013/mar/29/local/la-me-0330-rx-deaths-20130330)
They are discussing prescription painkillers. Drug fatalities are on the rise, seriously. These are deaths from overdose. So how do the authorities want to handle it? Limit the strength of the dosage and the quantity of drugs each day. The USDA (Drug Administration) is proposing a bill to do just that. They agree that there is great pain from cancer but they do not recognize much else.
You know how I write about the scientific notion of antecedent-consequent relations? That means that for every result there must some kind of cause. It is the cause that is left out of the equation by the FDA. They focus on the end result. So here is what they say: “The data supporting long-term use of opiates for pain, other than cancer is scant to non-existent.” I am not sure where they reside but it does not appear to be on this planet.
There seems to be no recognition of emotional pain. Since they cannot see and observe it, it must not exist. I am especially angry at this attitude because when I had back surgery years ago, the hospital, St Vincents, had no serious painkillers on board. Why? The state medical board was afraid they might addict their patients. So we suffered terribly. This is because they had no idea what addiction was or its provenance.
So what does the medical establishment suggest? Better computer control, tracking doctors who prescribe. They have found widespread abuse by a handful of corrupt doctors. And yes, they must be found and punished. But that doesn’t answer the question, why so much pain? Maybe it is pain on the rise, not just painkillers. Maybe drug use rises as pain does? And just maybe there is a reason beyond cancer (as they assume) for pain.
Clearly they have no notion of imprinted memory nor the kinds of great pain occasioned while we are in the womb and at birth. Indeed they do not recognize emotional pain at all. So if you hurt because your father was a drunk and raped you, it is not counted. Yet the pain I see every day makes a broken leg seem like a simple inconvenience. The screams I hear, the emotional torture, is never acknowledged in a culture where deep emotion is suspect. It is the General George Patton syndrome, get on with it, buck up and move on. I cannot believe this attitude in this day and age.
These officials are well defended and cannot empathize with those who are not. Those in power have to defend well to climb the corporate ladder. As I say, those who drink alcohol pass laws prohibiting the use of drugs for others. They would never consider alcohol a drug like Vicodin so they can vote to outlaw it. But if we voted “no alcohol” we would hear them scream.
So someone goes for back surgery and the hospital does offer painkillers, why does he get addicted? Because there is still more pain inside: emotional pain. That has to be quieted too. So he finally gets something to ease suffering he was never aware of before, pain from childhood. And for the first time, since emotional pain is not recognized, he gets something that makes him feel much better. Why shouldn’t he take that drug? I know, because the powers that be do not acknowledge emotions.
If we could once understand that early pain persists, is powerful and drives us, then we could comprehend what addiction is. It is the antecedent piece that is missing. But once we do understand then we can do something about it, something effective and long lasting; we could remove the pain from the system at last.
We cannot treat something we don’t recognize so we repress it. It will eventually kill the person prematurely. Those in power steal our lives; and they have no right to.
latest technology provides advanced monitoring...
ReplyDeletechildren, women and (why not?) men should wear little cameras to make sure their rights are respected. untill we develop technology that doesn't make us so sensible being. some hardware manipulation would be great!
latest progress in evolution of the species...
long live law, science and technology. and it is good for economy...
there is a hope!
what is real?????
as individuals and as a society we will die without ever to know what is real???
is that possible??? simple questions:
what is going on???
what is happening??
what and why we do when not sleeping
and when sleeping???
do we react? why we react as we react??
can we put it in numbers? bits? video frames?
arts? paragraphs? calories, kilograms and dates?
i woke up in the middle of the night
because the blanket was too thick and i sweat. ok...
but why confused and anxious??
i overeat probably.
i will change the blanket and not overeat tonight.
already feel better.
if you read this Art it is because
i have succesfully proved that i'm not a robot.
Killing the pain is the first order of business when the gating system is weak and the first line is constantly pushing through. Benzodiazepines and alcohol are great at killling the pain. (Unfortunately they're also great at giving rebound-anxiety and getting you addicted.) Having been a heavy daily benzo user for seven years, and also being a heavy drinker... let's just say I have more sympathy now for people who turn to drugs like heroin.
ReplyDeleteWhat troubles me though, is if I ever get to the Primal Center for therapy, first line intrusions are unavoidable. And I've developed quite a bit of tolerance to benzos. Are there other first line blockers used to fend off first line intrusions besides benzos? Seroquel probably won't do the job as I'm used to that also.
AnttiJ: yes there are but they are specific to each person. Our staff knows well what to use and when. art
DeleteThe neurotic dilemma!
ReplyDeleteWe do not know love's effects without experience what suffering without causing.
Frank
Hi Art,
ReplyDeleteIn various 'holistic systems' including Japanese Shiatsu, back pain is recognised as a correlator with a form of emotional pain known as 'lack of support'.
Also 'anxiety / terror' is know to affect the kidneys and repressed anger and rage affect the liver and spleen.
We humans are the only animals that walk upright on two feet with a frame evolved to stand on all four. All the compression goes to the lowest lumber vertebrae where inflamed kidneys can push close to and up against.
Blood flow becomes restricted, poisoning occurs followed by inflammation and mechanical damage of the cartilages. One bad load lifting experience and before you know it you're in surgery for a mechanical problem that certainly has it's origins in emotional pain.
The 'complimentary medicine' brigade in UK have become more influential in the NHS. Emotional pain is acknowledged here as a significant factor in disease but few comprehend the originating causes in early trauma. I wonder if eventually through this complementary route Primal may be better heard.
Unfortunately the 'alternatives' have also gained a charlatan's reputation due to too many false claims of cure when they can only ever be palliatives.
The court's out therefore, as to whether or not the complimentary brigade could help increase people's understanding of emotional pain or merely cloud it.
Paul G.
Cat on the rat, rat on the rope...
ReplyDeleteAccording to an article in the NYT, the PhRMA (The Pharmaceutical Research and Manufacturing of America) states that there are 60 million citizens in the US being more or less dependent on drugs to alleviate mental disorders and they remain strongly committed to the development of new drugs. This is fully in line with another article, also in the NYT, “Talk Doesn’t Pay, So Psychiatry Turns Instead to Drug Therapy” informing that many of the nation’s 48.000 psychiatrists no longer provide talk therapy; instead they prescribe medication after a brief consultation and send the patients away to less costly therapists with unexplored and unresolved personal crisis/pain.
Robert Whitaker is in his book “Anatomy Of An Epidemic” giving a picture of how mental health care has developed over the last 50-60 years and turned into an established epidemic. From 1954, when Thorazine was introduced, it kicked off a psychopharmacological revolution and antidepressants, and antianxiety agents were discovered and represented another leap forward in the treatment of mental disorders. In 2007, the US spent 25.000 million USD on antidepressants and antipsychotics.
So when you in your Reflections are saying that there is no recognition of mental pain there are apparently 60 million patients more or less depending on mental painkillers, and a pharmaceutical industry which is laughing all the way to the bank - as long as their patens are in force. With a documented decline in the number of talk therapies and considering that painkilling drugs are just short term symptom blockers, the Primal Therapy ought to be in an exceptionally good position if managed with professional responsibility.
Because of that I was successful in following the primal principal, I have, sadly enough, through my blog over a period had some letters of concern. In a summary, they say: “Our years in Primal Therapy have been lost, those in charge have stolen our lives and money, which they have no right to. It was not what they promised.” These letters are an eco of your last sentence in your latest Reflection.
Even if I sense that heavy feelings are involved, there is a practical reality to take into account. Who is responsible for that assessment / evaluation?
Truth and democracy must constantly be conquered.
Jan Johnsson
Jan, This is what I hope other bloggers do......expand on my blogs and round them out. I cannot do it all. art
Delete
DeleteJan You posted an interesting piece on cognitive therapy which I accidentally erased. Please send again. art
Thank you for this post, Art! You are absolutely right in what you have written.
ReplyDeleteI think neurotic socialites develop a culture of denial. All the people I work with, from day to day, collectively enforce a bullshit happy-mode that boils down to the denial (repression) of sadness. When exposed to a stimulant that should make them sad they will say "that's sad" but without an iota of feeling...they are in a mode that makes sure sadness can't be felt. You can just tell.
ReplyDeleteThe problem is their lives are as empty as their repressed souls because all they care about--or maybe even can care about--is avoiding the next anxiety attack. Alas!
Hi,
DeleteWell, to reveal (or revel in) sadness means to become vulnerable. Culture of denial is pseudo community. . . Nice. Nice in "quotation marks". . .
I mean it's inevitable that we have to be like that in large groups, to get by in the company of strangers. But what about the smaller support networks humans need to be real with each other? They used to call them extended family didn't they?
People might remember those if somehow the entire globe's TV sets and broadband connections were turned off for 36hrs.
Oh bloody hell ! ! We'd all have to face each other and remember who on earth we really are, warts and all.
Paul G.
And my answer: Good piece.Thanks. Well written. art
ReplyDeleteAnother email comment:
ReplyDelete"Hey Art,
I don't know if you'll ever read this but you're only touching the tip of the iceberg here!
You talk about cancer and diabetes as if they are diseases. They are not. They are the pain itself. If you want to see how deep the rabbit hole really is, you have to look beyond the construct we have created. You have to look beyond time, a construct we have invented to help us get through the pain. What is time if not projection of thoughts, feelings and actions into a future that does not exist?
Go deeper and you will discover your own pain along the way."
And my answer: What do you mean? art.
DeleteA facebook comment:
ReplyDelete"Pain-killers, prescription-drugs, street-drugs, cigarettes, alcohol all of which are poisonous, injurous, life-shortening and potentially lethal, not to mention a whole host of self-harm activies - self-starving, self-glutting, sharps-injury not to mention poor Amie Winehouse or poor Whitney Houston are all being reached for, en masse by virtually the entire population in order to repress one way or another emotional-experience and emotional-expression. Its emotionality itself that is being repressed, that is to say the emotinal process itself - in fine detail; sorrow, joy, love, hate, fear, anger, surprise, yearning - not just this or that emotional experience. The only time a person could be 'convinced' that 'emotional-repression' is the only way forward in life could only occur during childhood - once childhood is over an adult simply cannot be indoctrinated in this way. For an adult to 'convince' a child that the only way forward in life is to repress emotion is in fact a sophisticated and complicated social phenomena and require 'skill', determination and persistence on behalf of the adults. The child must be convinced that 'from now on I absolutely must repress my emotions' It cannot happen in the womb, it cannot happen by 'natural disaster' or 'natural trauma', it cannot happen by simple neglect or even abuse. It must come about by the child 'understanding' that that is what they must do. By these means 50,000 US 17 year olds were conscripted to their deaths in Vietnam. 'Self-repression of emtions is in fact what is giving rise to a whole host of social problems and horrors. In order to regain access once more to my experince of joy, sorrow, anger, fear, love, hate, surprise and yearning, in order to refrain from my own self repression of emotion I must make a concerted effort to return to those childhood days when I put in place the repressive control (with great encouragement from adults) and reactivate my own internal compass through life. Self-repression itself causes an enormous strain on the system and is of itself potentially lethal."
Words in itself want do it!
ReplyDeleteWhen I see people make an effort to intellectuals areas it is not difficult to see how impossible it is for them to explore other perspectives of life. Intellectuality in itself is a process that works in itself and prevents what intellectuals phenomena contain. It contains inteligence if used to the border where the pain begins. Primal therapy has to become official professional to achieve the status of being discovered.
"An inteligent man may be intellectual... but an intellectual is absolutely not not inleligent". This phenomenon... phenomenon for not being recognized among the intellectuals is a crucial problem since it requires emotional insight to explain itself.
Frank
Hi Art ,it is true: pains of the "body type" are easier to tolerate than the emotional ones.(of course only in the "natural degree" inflicted by normal..
ReplyDeletemaladies,injuries etc.) not those of for example the man induced ones-torture and the like!)
Some weeks ago I prefered an intestines investigation without drugs; the comforting of a (beautiful...) young lady was more than worth it!!
Each "morning terror" -(and throughout the day over years ) is worse than
these pain.
By the way I never had any relief by drugs!!
yours emanuel