There is a story in today’s paper about an alleged killer who murdered four police officers in Seattle. Here is someone who is a career criminal and who should have been in jail for the rest of his life. I’ll skip the details, which can be found in all major newspapers. This is a criminal with violent tendencies given freedom time after time, including being released by governor Mike Huckabee. Why did that happen? Ah, that is the question. Mostly because Baptist preachers often demand clemency for those who say that they see the light and have gone straight; and who have found God. You cannot get out of jail if you haven’t found that imaginary guy who sees all. Huckabee, who is so religious he doesn’t believe in evolution, listens to those preachers.
So what is it about them? Well, first of all, they all believe in forgiveness and redemption. And then they believe in what people say. And worse, they don’t believe in science; I mean, after all, if you don’t believe in one of the greatest scientific discoveries in history what are you doing on this planet? Recently scientists voted that evolution was one of the greatest discoveries in all of science. But the governor doesn’t listen to science; he listens to the forgivers, which is nice if you are talking about your mother but not about a killer. Lacking access to good sense and feeling they believe the words of psychopaths who use those words to deceive. And they deceive those self-deceivers because it is easy. And to be good Christians they want to forgive and believe that psychopaths turn good, which they don’t.
If you don’t see how people evolve what do you see? A static, unchanging world that is very predictable except when it isn’t. If you want to eschew forgiveness I have an idea. I do not forgive governor Huckabee for being gullible, stupid and in effect, criminal because he let loose a dangerous maniac onto us. Being forgiving makes us feel that we are so good but the result, as we see, is immoral.
And so why didn’t Huckabee listen to scientists and specialists in the field? Simple. He doesn’t believe in science. He believes in religion, and how many crimes are committed in the name of religion. Besides psychologic science, as I see it, is a failure.
In New Zealand those kinds of religious-associated decisions from judges are unheard of. It wouldn't be tolerated for a second, and it may be illegal here(?). But we let them out very early on, even if they have demonstrated that they capable of the worst. And they re-offend about 80% of the time, or something like that.
ReplyDeleteAnd another effect of those early releases is they go off have lots of kids - passing on their neurosis and expanding it for the rest of society to forever enjoy. The far-reaching costs are huge.
Art, I am not totally with you on this. There is always a 'Primal' reason why a guy is a killer, psychopath or a maniac. Just classifying it that was solves nothing and anyway who's doing the judging??? There is another side to this coin also, and that is the police. To the best of my ability as a primal patient (I am not a therapist nor have ever been trained), I see a very sad childhood with people that kill authority figures. It seems simple to me how the authority figures of his childhood dealt with him. I suspect also as he grew up his feelings got compounded until such time as his only response when someone was authoritarian over him (policemen) his rage overcame him. Violence, to me, is an overdose of anger, piling up for decades.
ReplyDeleteTo me, the police are a major part of the problem, the other is the politicians. You've gotta have a serious "Primal" problem to want to be a politician in the first place, cos for no better reason than they/us think they/us know how to solve the other guys behavior.
If humankind does not 'catch-onto' Primal Theory and see the full implications, then we are doomed to extinction. In the end, it is not that Dr. Arthur Janov discovered "Primal Pain' and formulated "Primal Theory" It only matters that it WAS discovered and the theory PROFFERED and that it gets serious consideration as to how we might circumvent NEUROSIS for the future generations.
Thank you for writing this. You should send this out as an editorial to the major papers, too.
ReplyDeleteHi Dr.Art Janov , I wonder why are there "psychopaths" ...? Because of a birth trauma , neglection et. in infancy , genetic disorders ..? Are these guys and ladies(ß) the exception to the rule (that "we all.." are the victoms of (parents, circumstances..) or are "they" so incurable like disabled by birth without a n y hope for recovery . I am strongly against letting people kill other people !! But d o the medicine better medisin .. (Christopher Barr ,a brother in faith ..by the way) not k i l l and all the others from the industrial complex .and no one puts them in prison for good .I know it is an aporectic situation (as the the philosophers would name it) Perhaps I can´t stand the imagine to put someone for ver in prison ,may be .. Yours emanuel
ReplyDeleteI think the problem is that most people just don't understand the psychopath. They don't understand how their minds work. Because it seems to be just too horrifying a concept for many people to grasp.
ReplyDeleteImagine a person who has never been allowed to express one single emotion their whole, entire childhood. Not one. If they did, (which is only natural for a developing child!) they would be beaten or otherwise sadistically punished by an uncaring parent. The child's second line is crushed between terror and rage to a point where it is unable to develop like it should have. It becomes withered to the point of being unable to function.
Eventually they adapt. Without any feelings to colour existence and allow empathy for another human being, their existence is a black and white picture of two instincts. Rage and terror. Fight or flight. It is that simple. If they are cunning enough, they can and do easily fake whatever feelings are necessary to fool whoever they need in order to rape, kill and butcher again and again in many unfortunate cases.
They can't 'see the light' for the same reason you can't teach a crocodile to have empathy for a small child. The only difference is that the crocodile is not intelligent enough to fool so many people. The psychopath is.
Too blunt for your blog I guess, but I am reminded of Judge Judy's two sayings I think Mr. Huckabee should learn:
'Don't piss on my leg and tell me it's raining'.
'Don't try and teach a pig to sing. It doesn't work, and it annoys the pig'.
an apt question. one that pertains to the world of someone with you expertise.
ReplyDeleteto quote a friend of mine:
"When your family or friend is murdered they do the best they can. When their own are murdered, not only do they find the murderer swiftly but they arrest the whole family with expediency. Why is that not done with a typical murder?"
best wishes,
h~
stories like this is why I talk about primal therapy to every person I meet. Without knowledge of the causes behind a killer, society is going to pretend that repression doesn't exist and put a happy face on it like Huckabee did (1) or just ignore it and put a tighter lid on them (2). It is such a relief to be optimistic about the future by seeing work in the psychology field becoming more scientific and integrated with biology/chemistry, rather than ideas and conjecture like id, hot seat, positivism, etc.
ReplyDelete(1)
The patient who has been incested isn’t plagued by negative thoughts; she is plagued by reality. It was terrible and she should feel terrible. Putting an optimistic face on it isn’t a positive step; it is a false one. That is truly negative. The way to be positive is to have a “negation of the negation.”
http://www.primaltherapy.com/GrandDelusions/GD01.htm
(2)
His rationale is appealing because it is simplistic. Push button two and you can resolve the problem. Throw money at the crime problem, build more prisons, punish the criminal more severely and you will solve the problem of crime.
http://www.primaltherapy.com/GrandDelusions/GD10.htm
Arthur, couple of questions:
ReplyDelete1) how do you assess psychosis in a prospective patient?
2) what is it that makes them psychotic? I'm assuming massive first line pain, but is there also brain 'damage' of some sort, either caused by that pain or in addition to it?
Erron
Cathy: You do it. AJ
ReplyDeleteEmanuel: Look in new book. Cannot write. I had an accident. AJ
ReplyDeleteHi Dr.Art I hope You`ll get w e l l soon!!! Yours emanuel
ReplyDeleteErron: I am laid up for a week or 3. I will answer this later. sorry art
ReplyDeleteI am sure that I speak for everyone in wishing you a speedy recovery from whatever accident you had. Last night, I re-read the essay "The Prolongation of Life " from "Primal Man"...as usual, absolutely fascinating...and important. Marco the Free Thinker
ReplyDeleteAs someone who had a violent childhood - I used to carry a baseball bat for protection, at the age of 6 each day when I went out to play, it's been my observation that violent people share a common emotional presentation.
ReplyDeleteI have also worked with several killers, who were on probation, and had mandated therapy as a part of their release.
I can say that killers and those who are violent, almost always have a primary emotional state of being - detached from others emotionally.
They don't feel connected to anyone, and learn to use violent intimidation as a way of getting what they want from others.